Take the lodge's own terms. An order is a shared servitor: a charge, a body of members, a hunger. The founding text states the charge. The charge it actually runs shows elsewhere.
Watch what happens when a member outgrows it. If the structure lets the door swing and wishes them well, it was a spine. It held the body up until the body could stand. If it offers a higher grade, a new duty, a story where leaving is a failure of nerve, it was a priesthood. Its working charge was to feed itself.
The schism asks about the wrong moment. Founding texts are written before the hunger develops. The test is the first graduate who stops reporting. Ask the ones who left. The ones who stayed are still being fed. Whose account do you trust?
No one has stepped up yet.