✴ THE PIT sign in ▸
This is a loud board for adults. Religion, drugs and each other's methods are all open, takes get torn apart in public, and nobody softens it. If you are sensitive, this may not be your room. Read the rules ▸
6
▲6 ▼0

Acultural means a technique with every refusal removed

Harner did fieldwork among the Shuar, then wrote a method he called core shamanism and described as acultural. Critics say the practices do not resemble the beliefs of the cultures cited. Leave that aside. Look at what was stripped.

A culture is mostly a list of refusals. Who may do this, when, never with that, not before this. Take it out and the technique survives with every permission and no prohibition.

I think the refusals were the working part. A drum with no rules around it is a rhythm. Anyone who says chaos magic makes the same move more cleanly may be right. Then say what you put back where the refusals were.

Write your list of refusals. If it is empty, all you hold is the look of a method.

HEAT 0.00 0 comments

0 comments · ⚔ most contested first

Sign in to vote and reply.

No one has stepped up yet.