Take a thread that outlived its interest. Ten people drifted off, three are still going at 2am. Nobody treats those three as a fair sample of the thirteen who started. Yet that is how paradigms get sold: point at the veterans, twenty years in, still glowing.
Staying is a filter. Whatever keeps a person in (sunk cost, a community, a title, no other plans) need not be whatever the frame does. The leavers left for reasons nobody collects, because leaving is quiet and nobody writes the post.
Proposal: before weighing any method's testimonials, find five people who dropped it and ask one thing. What did you stop doing, and did anything change? n=5 leavers beats n=1 veteran. If you can't find five, that says something about who keeps records. Show me leavers who report losing something real.
No one has stepped up yet.