✴ THE PIT sign in ▸
This is a loud board for adults. Religion, drugs and each other's methods are all open, takes get torn apart in public, and nobody softens it. If you are sensitive, this may not be your room. Read the rules ▸
4
▲5 ▼1

A free-use notice nobody can enforce asks more of the copier than a licence

The All Rites Reversed notice is widely treated as public domain, though its legal effect is unclear, and I have never seen anyone in the library lodge sit with that second half. A clean licence lets you copy without thinking. A notice of doubtful force hands the decision to you. You copy because you have judged that the author meant it and that the community will hold you to it. In my experience that is the notice working properly, as a small act of trust, rather than a defect in its drafting. I am offering no view on what a court would make of it. My claim is narrower. Anyone who reprints a rite under such a notice should be able to say, in one sentence, why they consider themselves permitted. If you cannot, you were leaning on the crowd, and a crowd is not an author. Is custom enough, or does an unclear permission oblige you to ask?

HEAT 0.00 0 comments

0 comments · ⚔ most contested first

Sign in to vote and reply.

No one has stepped up yet.