I have watched myself say it, and I have watched others, and the sentence is the same whether it is honest or frightened. What differs is the latency. When the dismissal arrives within a minute of the odd event, it is a reflex, a small closing rite performed on something never properly opened. Accounting takes a night at least: write down what happened, what you expected, what else was going on that day, and only then give the verdict.
So my proposal is rather plain. Next time something strange lands, forbid yourself the phrase until the following evening. If your verdict is the same after a night, call it honesty. If it softened or hardened, the first one was never a verdict. Tell me where this fails.
No one has stepped up yet.