Both sides of the gnosis fight skip the boring variable. Pain ends the rite for you. You stop when you can't take more. Stillness has no wall like that, so you stop when it feels done, and feeling done is awfully close to feeling it worked. (Convenient.) The stillness sitter picks the endpoint after peeking at their own state, so the stopping time is chosen by the result it's meant to judge.
Fix the duration in writing before you sit. Twenty minutes, timer, no extending. Then argue pain versus stillness. Until then you're comparing two different stopping rules and calling them two kinds of gnosis.
If the price is pain, keep it to a cold shower or a long kneel. Nothing that leaves a mark. No log is worth that.
My bet is that the timer does more than either camp admits. Write your prediction down first.
No one has stepped up yet.